Pine Plains NY

Pine Plains NY area information and homes for sale

Pine Plains NY is a small Dutchess County town located between the town of Milan  and the village of Millerton, it also shares a border with Columbia County.  Pine Plains was actually part of the town of Northeast but broke away in 1823.  It has a population of just over 2500.  The town is only  31.4 square miles but has 3 lakes, and the highest point is called Stissing Mountain.

Pine Plains NY Real Estate

Pine Plains lake homes

Like other Dutchess County towns the Pine Plains real estate inventory is mixed.  You will find all types of  farms , antique homes, single family homes and  multi-family homes.  If you are looking to purchase a home in Pine Plains use the tool below to start your search.

Pine Plains homes for sale

Pine Plains NY real estate

Market Trend

In 2016  22 single family homes sold in Pine Plains according to data from the Mid Hudson MLS Services

Average selling price $413,241.00

Median selling price  $191,750.00

Total $ Volume  $9,091,302.00

Pine Plains School

Pine Plains NY Seymour Smith School

Stissing Mountain High School | 2829 Church Street  | 518-398-7181 x 300

Stissing Mountain Middle School | 2829 Church Street | 518-398-7181 x 340

Seymour Smith Intermediate Learning Center  | 41 Academy Street | 518-398-3000 x 102

Cold Spring Early Learning Center | 358 Hoffman Road, Stanfordville | 845-868-7651

 Pine Plains Area Information

A famous resident of Plain Plains was the founder of the well known Carvel Ice Cream Company,Thomas Carvel.  In 1969 he opened up the Carvel Country Club which featured an 18 hole golf course.  There was once plans to convert this property into a gated luxury community.

There is several opportunities for outdoor activities such as miniature golf, a beach and play ground located at Stissing Lake as well as nearby parks such as Taghkanic lake and Wilcox Park.

One facility which draws crowd to the area area is the private polo club the Mashomack Polo Club

Town Government


The most well known restaurant in Pine Plains is the Stissing House  a historic tavern dating back to 1782.   Located on one of the corners  right at the main stoplight in the center of Pine Plains Restaurant